Writing and inspiration
"Love Story" came along late into the production of
Fearless.
[4] Swift wrote "Love Story" about a man who was never officially her boyfrind. When she introduced him to her family and friends, they did not become fond of him.
[5] "His situation was a little complicated, but I didn't care", said Swift.
[6] Swift also felt like it was the first time she could relate to the plot of William Shakespeare's
Romeo and Juliet (1597), one of her favorite narratives, which she described as, "The only people who wanted them to be together were them.
[5] She conceived the idea for the song when she reflected about the scenario: "I thought, 'This is difficult but it's real, it matters—it's not simple or easy but it's real'." She then centered the song on the line, which was ultimately placed in the "Love Story"'s second refrain.
[7] All events, with the exclusion of the end, narrated in the song regarded Swift's actual story. The song's conclusion differed from that of
Romeo and Juliet. "I feel like they had such promise and they were so crazy for each other. And if that had just gone a little bit differently, it could have been the best love story ever told. And it is one of the best love stories ever told, but it's a tragedy." Instead, she chose to write a happy ending.
[8] She took her favorite characters and conceptualized the ending she believed they deserved.
[9] She perceived it to be the ideal ending that girls hoped for, including herself.
[7] "You want a guy who doesn’t care what anyone thinks, what anyone says." Although it was fictional, Swift said it was an enjoyable experience to write about.
[6] Swift wrote the track on her bedroom floor in approximately twenty minutes, feeling too inspired to put the song down unfinished.
[5]
Swift and her love interest continued their relationship, but then separated because it was hard for them to see each other.
[8] To Swift, the song resembles much optimism regarding love and how encountering the right person could surpass skepticism.
[9] She deemed "Love Story" one of her most romantic songs, although she was never in an official relationship with the subject of the song
[5] In retrospect, Swift said the song is "about a love that you've got to hide because for whatever reason it wouldn't go over well", adding "I spun it in the direction of
Romeo and Juliet. Our parents are fighting. I relate to it more as a love that you cannot really elaborate on — a love that maybe society wouldn't accept [or] maybe your friends wouldn't accept."
[10]
Recording
Swift performing "Love Story" on the Fearless Tour.
"Love Story" was recorded in March 2008 at Blackbird Studios in Nashville, Tennessee, alongside record producer Nathan Chapman and various personnel.
[11] Swift sang into an Avantone CV-12 multi-pattern tube microphone, manufactured by Avant Electronics. The microphone had a new old stock tube that was designed and built by country singer, record producer, and audio engineer Ray Kennedy for Chapman. Chapman had received the microphone from Kennedy as a loan, as a "try this for a while" experiment. Although he previously had tested numerous microphones on Swift, he had not been able to find one to match her voice perfectly. When Swift came to Chapman's home to record a radio edit for one of the singles from
Taylor Swift, she immediately grew fond of the microphone.
[11] "When she put on the headphones and said, 'Test,' completely unprompted, she said, 'This is my mic. I love this mic. I just wanna use this one from now on!' She had no idea what it was, just loved it, and I went along with something that felt right for her. We've been using it ever since, and it sounds great on her voice," Chapman said.
[11]
"Love Story" was recorded with Pro Tools and tracking vocals, which Swift sang live with the band. The band consisted of acoustic guitars, bass guitars, and drums.
[1] All other instruments were overdubbed by Chapman. He said, "I think there are nine acoustic guitars on that track, and I stacked several background vocals — me singing, 'Ah's'."
[11] Audio engineering was executed by Chad Carlson in Blackbird Studios' Studio D, with the usage of the API Legacy Plus equipments: Avantone CV-12, Neve 1073, and Tube-Tech CL-1B. Audio mixing done by Justin Niebank and was set in Studio F, with the usage of the console Solid State Logic 9080 K series and Genelec 1032 console. In between, overdubs were executed in Studio E by Chapman.
[11] "Love Story", along with the rest of the album, was mastered by Hank Williams at MasterMix Studios in Nashville, Tennessee.
[1] The song was mixed for mainstream airplay by Chapman. He pulled Niebank's stems into his Mac OS laptop and used Apple Logic to create the pop version. Chapman made mix tweaks and created new elements with his laptop. In order to do so, he muted the country instruments and replaced them with new elements characteristic to pop music, replacing banjo and fiddle with electric guitar. The pop version's opening beat is a Logic loop in the Ultrabeat beat generator. All the new electric guitars were done with the Amplitube Stomp I/O.
[11]
Composition
|
"Love Story" (2008)
A 24-second audio sample of Taylor Swift's "Love Story", a midtempo number that narrates from the perspective of the fictional character Juliet Capulet.
|
Problems playing this file? See media help. |
"Love Story" is a country pop song with a length of three minutes and 54 seconds.
[12] It is set in common time and has a moderate tempo of 120 beats per minute
[13] It is written in the key of D major and Swift's vocals span one octave, from A
3 to B
4.
[13] Swift croons "Love Story" softly and sweetly,
[14][15] with a slight twang.
[16] It follows the chord progression D (add)
9–Asus
4–Bm–G
69.
[13] The song is of a swirling and dreamy soprano. The melody is simple, containing a rushy pace which continually grows and concludes with a key change to E major.
[14]
The lyrics of "Love Story" are written in first person, in which Swift refers to herself as the
Romeo and Juliet character Juliet Capulet and her love interest as Romeo Montague.
[16] Fraser McAlpine of the BBC described the song as a narrative, in which Swift is the narrator.
[14] The song's plot revolves a youthful romance foiled by parental disapproval. In the end, love prevails and the couple finds their "happily ever after".
[15] The first verse introduces the characters at a ball, where they meet.
[14] In the second verse, the story transitions to the couple sneaking about after dark
[14] and references Nathaniel Hawthorne's
The Scarlet Letter (1850).
[17] The song's refrains have Swift waiting for her love interest to appear: "Romeo, take me somewhere we can be alone/ I'll be waiting/ All there's left to do is run."
[16] The song's final refrain has Swift narrating from Romeo's perspective
[18] and proposing marriage to Swift.
[6]
Critical reception
"Love Story" was highly acclaimed by critics upon release. Kate Kiefer of
Paste magazine recognized the song to be Swift's best and added that once the lyrics are learned, it is impossible to not sing along.
[19] Sean Dooley of About.com credited the song for transitioning Swift from a "fresh-faced star to crossover superstar". Dooley attributed the song's commercial success due to her departure from her past lyrical themes, which summarized "I wish this boy knew how I really felt about him".
[20] While reviewing
Fearless, Dooley selected "Love Story" as one of the best tracks on the album.
[21] Jonathan Keefe of Slant Magazine admired how Swift attempted to incorporate sophisticated elements, like
Romeo and Juliet and
The Scarlet Letter, although it was not successful because of its awkwardness, inexplicable nature, and pointless conceit. Keefe credited its success to its prominent hook.
[17] James Reed of
The Boston Globe thought otherwise, stating Swift's charm was in her songwriting skills.
[16]
Fraser McAlpine of the BBC stated, "'Love Story' is a stunning pop song and, because it really does tell a love story, it's heart-warming and draws the listener into the exciting and romantic fairytale world."
[14] However, she felt Swift's vocal performance was not incredible, but was passionate to complement the song's sentiments. McAlpine resumed by stating that "Love Story", although obvious, a bit dramatic, and probably targeted towards younger audiences, was just lovely and that Swift proved herself a true princess of pop with the song.
[14] Chris Neal of
Weekly called "Love Story" an "ebullient first hit."
[22] Deborah Evans Price of
Billboard magazine gave the single a favorable review and called it an "enchanting offering". Price noted that "Love Story" demonstrates one of Swift's appeals, her writing and singing of age-appropriate material that can be both relatable to her audience and others. As a result, she predicted the song would have much commercial success in the country music industry.
[15] Alex Macpherson of British newspaper
The Guardian described the song to be by a "joyous rush" that, according to him, was later replicated by Swift's own single "" (2010).
[23] of Country listed the song at number 17 on its list of greatest country songs of all time.
[24 In 2017, ShortList's Dave Fawbert listed the song as containing "one of the greatest key changes in music history".